Geoffrey is slain for the a cycling collision from inside the 1186 and you may Constance married (2) Ranulph de Blundeville, 4 th Earl regarding Chester, on the step 3 rd February 1188, inside the a wedding setup because of the King Henry eleven. That it relationship deteriorated and you can Ranulph imprisoned Constance during the 1196. Rebellions was indeed stimulated across the Brittany on her and Ranulph released their unique within the 1198. Back in Brittany, Constance had their relationship annulled and later for the 1198, she got Man de Tours due to the fact their unique ‘second’ spouse.

Constance passed away old 40, (perhaps out of leprosy, maybe following childbirth in order to dual girls) towards the 5 th September 1201 within Nantes

Although this wasn’t an effective consanguineous relationships but certainly one of affinity, one earliest-training matchmaking might have made relationship ranging from Constance and some of John’s brothers hopeless in the place of a good dispensation –– and that considering the party’s score would have needed to are from new pope himself

The idea you to definitely Constance had an affair with John following the death of Geoffrey and you can ahead of John’s relationship to Isabella off Gloucester inside the 1189, and therefore she is mom so you’re able to Joanna is really contentious and you will has provoked much discussion in this genealogical circles.

One to opinion from a good genealogist states you to definitely ‘the new record ‘Brand new Plantagenet Connection’ has actually authored a keen ahnentafel of Elizabeth Plantagenet, partner off Henry V11, that provides Joanna’s mother’s identity while the Constance (maybe misnamed Clemence?), Duchess regarding Brittany. This is actually the Constance who was simply John’s sis-in-law! Considering the well-recognized animosity anywhere between John and you will Constance along with her very own tries to force their own child Arthur’s interests as much as the fresh new throne out of The united kingdomt is actually alarmed (and we also all the know how disastrously you to proved!), I must say i get the recommended matchmaking a small tough to take. The brand new Constance one to records illustrates will not struck me personally given that towards whom John could easily coerce on the bed.’

‘ A theory that would identify Joanna’s mother because the Constance fails to take into account a very vital point in cannon rules. Who does signify specific trace of count have to surely came down to united states, if it inside the request they, the fresh new deliberations, or even the actual dispensation itself. As far as i in the morning aware, little of the form is obtainable.’

Of the merely that have sex with John, not to mention results your a baby, Constance might have oriented a primary-knowledge dating out of attraction along with John’s siblings –– in addition to John’s brother Geoffrey

personal view for just what it’s worth, is the fact got Constance already been mom off Joanna she’d positively have put their own up in her home along with her name is also labeled as Constance’s almost every other children from the Geoffrey (Eleanor, Reasonable Maid out-of Brittany, Matilda/Maud off Brittany and you can Arthur).

Agatha came into this world regarding 1168 into the Chartley Castle, Staffordshire. It’s notorious one she is a domme out-of John and many friends woods offer their unique, although unmarried, given that mommy of Joanna. Very genealogists although not believe that it is simply supposition that she is Joanna’s mother as the no proof otherwise details exist to display which.

One supply seem to provided is actually Sir William Dugdale, throughout the Baronage from England (1675-6). According to him their origin to get Dr David Howell’s ‘History of Wales’ (1584). Powell’s tasks are an expanded edition from H Lloyd’s interpretation of ‘The brand new Historie off Cambria’ from the 12 th century Saint Caradoc from Llancarfan. A special resource, ‘Magna Carta Barons’ from the Charles Browning, copyright laws 1969 also labels Agatha de- Ferrers, daughter regarding Robert de Ferrers, last Earl of derby, due to the fact Joanna’s mom.

In the event she can not be entirely ignored given that an applicant for mom away from Joanna, positively there is particular shade away from their own in the a good chronicle or other historic source, in the event that she got actually started the mother of partner away from the new Prince away from Northern Wales https://brightwomen.net/no/bangladesh-kvinner/.